Illinibucks
Implementing
a system such as Illinibucks would allow students to cut the lines on weight
lists. The weight lists they would be able to skip would be clearly defined by
the University. These could start with weighting to register for classes.
Registering for classes is based on whether you are an athlete or are a James
Scholar. It is also based on age, and making sure seniors can get the classes
they need to graduate. If you used
illinibucks to skip into the front of the priority line, it may make it easier
for a younger student who maybe is a double major and needs to fit into
specific classes his junior year because he has a very tight schedule.
In
addition, these Illinibucks could skip a weight list like that of a line at
Mckinely. Mckinely, especially during the winter months becomes very busy.
These illinibucks would allow you to see a doctor right away if you were sick.
Another way
of using illinibucks could be skipping the weight list for dorms maybe one’s
freshman year. If enough were bought, you could request to be put in the same
dorm as a large group of your friends.
My main
problem with a system like illinibucks is that these weight lists point more
towards seniority. Would it really be fair if a freshman in college was able to
take a class that a senior could not get into because they could afford
purchasing Illibucks. The allocation of these resources provided at the University
has a set system on giving the priority to those that deserve it. Of course
seniors need to have higher priority because they need to take classes to
graduate. Athletes at our school need higher priority because they need to be
able to mold their schedule around when they have games and practices. Those
that are not on sports teams should not have that problem.
For
housing, if one was able to purchase a spot at a dorm that is giving those more
privileged an unfair advantage. At Mckinley this is also allowing money to take
priority over the severity of someone’s health.
One tweak
to be made to this system could possibly be how the University exchanges these
Illinibucks. What if instead of purchasing them with money these were
purchasing with GPA. However, this system may not be fair to those in
engineering with harder majors than a vast majority of others on this campus.
Maybe one’s class rank, that would get rid of the limiting factor of variety in
major. However, again back to fairness of allocation. Does the University
punish those whose GPA may be low one semester?
Instead of
using systems such as Illinibucks, the system becomes fixed itself. Constantly
humans try to attach add ons or clauses to already set laws. If we could focus
more on how do we efficiently allocate class times and room assignments so that
the majority of students are able to register for a schedule that fits for
them. At Mckinely, the wait listing comes from many student who refuse to make
an appointment before going in. Therefore, those who actually do need immediate
attention are forced to wait longer.
As for the
dorm, recently the university has been making attempts at updating the older
rooms. However, this goes back to my view on seniority in an educational
setting. Upperclassmen still living in dorms should be on top priority, and
those that are freshman also have other options such as private certified housing.
Wait lists, not weight lists.
ReplyDeleteYou might ask whether the seniority system is ideal or if every once in a while it would be good for the allocation to be based on other than seniority. If the Illinibucks price was pretty high, then the seniority system would remain intact most of the time. But when the student felt an urgent need to cut into the line, then that would be possible.
I find the McKinley example troublesome. If you need some pill to combat a bug that is going around, do you really have to wait several days to get that. It would seem to make the bug spread more in the meantime. That is troublesome.
I agree with you that there are some moral problems with the Illini bucks system. The U of I selling out for preferential treatment definitely won't sit well with many people. I also was a little unsettled by the McKinley example. Personally I think healthcare is an area where we should do our best to let our morality overrule economic laws, but I know that's not always possible.
ReplyDeleteOne way that I think that we could bypass all of this is to give every student an equal amount of Illini bucks at the beginning of each semester and allow them to spend them on processes that the University randomizes anyways. For example, you would not be able to spend Illini bucks to preferentially select classes before every student, but you could spend them to pick your classes before anyone else with your class standing (because uiuc randomizes the picking order after that).